Prickly Pear Bar and Restaurant
Caribbean, Seafood, BBQ, American, Anguillian
$$$
Prickly Pear Cay, 6 miles north of Road Bay, Anguilla
Opens at 11:00 AM
Lunch • 11:00 AM - 4:00 PM
+1 264-235-1906
Beach casual / barefoot dining
Save, share, or print this restaurant
Keep this dining spot handy while planning your Anguilla trip.
About Prickly Pear Bar and Restaurant
Prickly Pear Bar and Restaurant is one of Anguilla's most unique dining experiences, set on the uninhabited Prickly Pear Cay located six miles north of Road Bay. The small pair of islands -- Prickly Pear East and Prickly Pear West, divided by a narrow boat channel -- are accessible by boat only, making every visit feel like a private island escape. The restaurant serves family-style all-inclusive dining packages on the beach, with tables set in the sand and panoramic views of the Caribbean Sea. The menu is served as per-person packages: the Family Style Dining package at $35 per person includes grilled mahi mahi, grilled chicken breast, BBQ baby back pork ribs, Caribbean rice and peas, sauteed potatoes, coleslaw and garden green salad. The Family Style Lobster Dining package at $65 per person adds grilled whole lobster to the above. The Ultimate Family Style + Drinks package at $135 per person includes the full spread plus Pirate Cay Rum Shrimp, and an open bar with all mixed drinks, rum punch, wines, sodas and water. Activities available for rent include paddleboard, kayak, snorkeling gear, and seabob. Beach massages and hiking/bird watching tours are available on request. Private dining, live entertainment, and custom event planning are available. Group reservations for 10-30 persons are accepted with customized buffet menus.
The Vibe
beachfront, oceanfront, ocean_view, waterfront, open_air, feet_in_the_sand, casual, casual_beach, lively, fun, festive, relaxed, laidback, beachy, local, authentic, touristy, family_friendly, kid_friendly, group_friendly, date_night, romantic, special_occasion, luxury, lunch, beach_lunch, seafood, local_food, caribbean, caribbean_food, anguillian, lobster, fish, mahi, bbq, barbecue, grill, rum_punch, beer, cocktails, live_music, live_entertainment, reservations, private_dining, events, wedding_friendly, beach_chairs, umbrella_rental, moderate
Known For
Grilled Whole Lobster (Ultimate and Lobster packages), Pirate Cay Rum Shrimp (Ultimate package only), Grilled Mahi Mahi, BBQ Baby Back Pork Ribs, Grilled 8oz Breast of Chicken, Caribbean Rice and Peas, Sauteed Potatoes, Rum Punch (included in Ultimate Family Style open bar), All Mixed Drinks (included in Ultimate Family Style open bar), Wines (included in Ultimate Family Style open bar), Sodas and Water (included in all packages), American
Ideal For
Quick Facts
Cuisine
Caribbean, Seafood, BBQ, American, Anguillian
Dining Style
beachfront, oceanfront, ocean_view, waterfront, open_air, feet_in_the_sand, casual, casual_beach, lively, fun, festive, relaxed, laidback, beachy, local, authentic, touristy, family_friendly, kid_friendly, group_friendly, date_night, romantic, special_occasion, luxury, lunch, beach_lunch, seafood, local_food, caribbean, caribbean_food, anguillian, lobster, fish, mahi, bbq, barbecue, grill, rum_punch, beer, cocktails, live_music, live_entertainment, reservations, private_dining, events, wedding_friendly, beach_chairs, umbrella_rental, moderate
Price Level
$$$
Parking
Prickly Pear Cay is located 6 miles north of Road Bay, Anguilla and is accessible by boat only. Boat transfer arrangements are the responsibility of the guest -- water taxis and charter boats available from Sandy Ground, Road Bay, and Island Harbour. The restaurant does not operate a boat shuttle from the official website. Contact +1 264-235-1906 for guidance on boat access.
Beach Access
Yes
Takeout
Not listed
Accessibility
Not listed
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Pet Friendly
Not listed
Local notes
Dining Tips
A few quick details to help your visit feel smooth.
Reservations
Reservations required. Book at pricklypearanguilla.com/reservations/ or call +1 264-235-1906 or email info@pricklypearanguilla.com. Group reservations for 10-30 persons available. Private dining, live entertainment, and events available on request.
Best Timing
Peak season November through April is the busiest time. Weekends and public holidays book up quickly. Reserve well in advance especially for groups.
Dress Code
Beach casual / barefoot dining
Service Note
Service charge and tax not listed on the official website. Confirm current rates when making your reservation.
Popular Dishes
Grilled Whole Lobster (Ultimate and Lobster packages)
Private island dining on Prickly Pear Cay, 6 miles from Anguilla. Boat access only. Family packages from $35/pp: grilled mahi mahi, BBQ ribs, chicken, Caribbean sides. Lobster package $65/pp. Open bar package $135/pp. Snorkeling, paddleboard, kayak on site.
Pirate Cay Rum Shrimp (Ultimate package only)
Private island dining on Prickly Pear Cay, 6 miles from Anguilla. Boat access only. Family packages from $35/pp: grilled mahi mahi, BBQ ribs, chicken, Caribbean sides. Lobster package $65/pp. Open bar package $135/pp. Snorkeling, paddleboard, kayak on site.
Grilled Mahi Mahi
Private island dining on Prickly Pear Cay, 6 miles from Anguilla. Boat access only. Family packages from $35/pp: grilled mahi mahi, BBQ ribs, chicken, Caribbean sides. Lobster package $65/pp. Open bar package $135/pp. Snorkeling, paddleboard, kayak on site.
Explore the Menu
Family Style Dining Package
Grilled Mahi Mahi, Grilled 8oz Breast of Chicken, BBQ Baby Back Pork Ribs, Caribbean Rice and Peas, Sauteed Potatoes, Coleslaw, and Garden Green Salad. Family-style, served on the beach. All items included per person. Sodas and water included.
Family Style Lobster Dining Package
Grilled Whole Lobster, Grilled Mahi Mahi, Grilled 8oz Breast of Chicken, BBQ Baby Back Pork Ribs, Caribbean Rice and Peas, Sauteed Potatoes, Garden Green Salad, and Coleslaw. Family-style, served on the beach. All items included per person.
Ultimate Family Style + Open Bar Package
Grilled Whole Lobster, Pirate Cay Rum Shrimp, Grilled Mahi Mahi, Grilled 8oz Breast of Chicken, BBQ Baby Back Pork Ribs, Caribbean Rice and Peas, Garden Green Salad, Coleslaw, and Sauteed Potatoes. PLUS Open Bar: all mixed drinks, rum punch, wines, sodas and water. Family-style, served on the beach.
Leave a Review
Share your experience with other travelers.
Information missing or incorrect? Help us update this listing →
Eating at Prickly Pear Bar and Restaurant?
Sort out transport, timing, and nearby beach plans around your meal.
Help Keep Anguilla Ferry Times Free
Anguilla Ferry Times helps travelers check ferry schedules, service alerts, taxi fares, beach conditions, travel guides, and essential island information in one place. Your support helps keep the platform useful, up-to-date, and free for everyone.
Every contribution helps improve the tools travelers rely on.
Support helps cover hosting, maintenance, content updates, data improvements, and new travel planning features for locals and visitors.
Free
Always free to use
Daily
Schedule updates
100%
Community supported
Ferry schedule support
Helps keep ferry routes, times, and travel details easy to find.
Reliable local updates
Supports service notices, travel alerts, and helpful planning content.
Better travel tools
Funds improvements to taxi, beach, ferry, and island planning tools.
Want to support future improvements?
Contributions help us add better schedule tools, alerts, travel guides, ferry planning features, and local visitor resources.