The FishTrap
Caribbean, Seafood, American, Bar Food, Anguillian
$
Island Harbour, Anguilla (across from Falcon's Nest)
Opens at 11:30 AM
Lunch • 11:30 AM - 4:00 PM
+1 264-584-3474
Casual / beach casual
Save, share, or print this restaurant
Keep this dining spot handy while planning your Anguilla trip.
About The FishTrap
The FishTrap is a beloved Island Harbour restaurant and bar set directly across from Falcon's Nest, with a spacious open dining area overlooking the harbour. A firm favourite with locals and visitors for fresh, affordable Caribbean seafood. The full menu covers wings in five preparations (Regular, Pineapple Glazed, Rum Glazed, Lemon Pepper, Spicy), quesadillas, tacos, salads, fish (Pot Fish, Choice Fish, Lobster by size), burgers, and pastas, all with protein choices including chicken, fish, shrimp, lobster, and steak. No service charge or GST is added. The bar serves a wide selection of beers, spirits (shots and mixed), and cocktail specials. Live band on Sundays. Ask about the daily special.
The Vibe
island_harbour, harbour, beachfront, oceanfront, beach_bar, open_air, casual, lively, fun, local, authentic, family_friendly, kid_friendly, group_friendly, lunch, dinner, seafood, local_food, caribbean, caribbean_food, anguillian, fish, lobster, burgers, tacos, pasta, cocktails, rum_punch, beer, live_music, live_entertainment, walk_ins, affordable, vegetarian_options
Known For
Fish and Chips, Mahi Mahi, Shrimp Pasta, Seafood Pasta, Pineapple Glazed Wings, Rum Glazed Wings, Pot Fish, Lobster Quesadilla, Lobster Tacos, Lobster Burger, Daiquiri or Mojito, Margarita, Pina Colada, Malibu Sunset, Rum Punch, Full Bar, American, Bar Food
Ideal For
Quick Facts
Cuisine
Caribbean, Seafood, American, Bar Food, Anguillian
Dining Style
island_harbour, harbour, beachfront, oceanfront, beach_bar, open_air, casual, lively, fun, local, authentic, family_friendly, kid_friendly, group_friendly, lunch, dinner, seafood, local_food, caribbean, caribbean_food, anguillian, fish, lobster, burgers, tacos, pasta, cocktails, rum_punch, beer, live_music, live_entertainment, walk_ins, affordable, vegetarian_options
Price Level
$
Parking
Located in Island Harbour directly across from Falcon's Nest. Spacious dining area and bar. Parking available nearby.
Beach Access
Yes
Takeout
Not listed
Accessibility
Not listed
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Pet Friendly
Not listed
Local notes
Dining Tips
A few quick details to help your visit feel smooth.
Reservations
Walk-ins welcome. Call +1 264-584-3474 to confirm hours or check on daily specials.
Best Timing
Sundays with live band are popular. A local favourite in Island Harbour.
Dress Code
Casual / beach casual
Service Note
No service charge or GST added. Confirmed on official menu images.
Popular Dishes
Fish and Chips
Island Harbour seafood restaurant with no service charge or GST. Fresh fish, wings, quesadillas, tacos, burgers, and pastas at honest prices. Live band Sundays.
Mahi Mahi
Island Harbour seafood restaurant with no service charge or GST. Fresh fish, wings, quesadillas, tacos, burgers, and pastas at honest prices. Live band Sundays.
Shrimp Pasta
Island Harbour seafood restaurant with no service charge or GST. Fresh fish, wings, quesadillas, tacos, burgers, and pastas at honest prices. Live band Sundays.
Explore the Menu
Regular Wings
Classic fried chicken wings. Wings only $5, with fries $10.
Pineapple Glazed Wings
Wings with pineapple glaze. Wings only $7, with fries $12.
Rum Glazed Wings
Wings with rum glaze. Wings only $7, with fries $12.
Lemon Pepper Wings
Wings with lemon pepper seasoning. With fries $12.
Spicy Wings
Wings with spicy seasoning. With fries $12.
Spice level: hot
Leave a Review
Share your experience with other travelers.
Information missing or incorrect? Help us update this listing →
Eating at The FishTrap?
Sort out transport, timing, and nearby beach plans around your meal.
Help Keep Anguilla Ferry Times Free
Anguilla Ferry Times helps travelers check ferry schedules, service alerts, taxi fares, beach conditions, travel guides, and essential island information in one place. Your support helps keep the platform useful, up-to-date, and free for everyone.
Every contribution helps improve the tools travelers rely on.
Support helps cover hosting, maintenance, content updates, data improvements, and new travel planning features for locals and visitors.
Free
Always free to use
Daily
Schedule updates
100%
Community supported
Ferry schedule support
Helps keep ferry routes, times, and travel details easy to find.
Reliable local updates
Supports service notices, travel alerts, and helpful planning content.
Better travel tools
Funds improvements to taxi, beach, ferry, and island planning tools.
Want to support future improvements?
Contributions help us add better schedule tools, alerts, travel guides, ferry planning features, and local visitor resources.