Best Car Rental Companies in Anguilla
Compare Anguilla's top car rental agencies by rating, price, pickup location, vehicle type, service style, and best use case.
Top rated
4.9
Bryan's Car Rentals
Starting from
$30/day
Wendell Connor Car Rentals
Pickup options
Airport + Ferry
All three agencies offer arrival pickup
Vehicle types
Economy–4x4
Choose based on your route plans
Why the right rental agency makes a real difference in Anguilla
Anguilla is a small island (just 16 miles long), but a rental car is the single most practical way to explore it. Taxis are available, but the freedom to move between beaches, villages, restaurants, and hidden coves on your own schedule is what most visitors remember most. That freedom starts with the right rental agency.
Most visitors rent from local Anguillan agencies rather than international brands. Operators like Bryan's Car Rentals, Andy's Auto Rentals, and Wendell Connor Car Rentals have built their reputations over years of serving travelers arriving by air and ferry. They know which vehicles handle rougher beach roads, they can meet you at the airport or ferry terminal, and they typically offer straightforward service without the overhead of large corporate rental desks.
Choosing the right company depends less on price alone and more on a combination of factors: where you arrive, what you plan to do, how many people are in your group, and how much you value convenience. A contactless pickup model might suit solo travelers and couples best. A minivan fleet and multiple pickup locations matter most for families. Clear WhatsApp-based communication is often more practical on a small island than formal reservation systems.
This guide ranks and reviews Anguilla's top local rental agencies by rating, starting rate, pickup convenience, vehicle selection, and service style, so you can match the agency to your actual trip.
The best company depends on how you arrive and how you plan to explore.
If you want the simplest overall experience, choose a rental company with airport pickup, ferry terminal pickup, hotel delivery, clear pricing, and easy communication.
If your trip is mostly beach hopping, compact cars work for many visitors. If you plan to visit rougher beach roads, hidden coves, or remote areas, ask about SUV or 4x4 options before booking.
Best overall
Bryan's Car Rentals
Choose this if you want the easiest all-around rental experience: cars pre-positioned at your arrival point, contactless pickup, and a strong track record of service.
Best value
Andy's Auto Rentals
Choose this if you want a practical daily rental from a well-established agency and care most about keeping transportation costs reasonable.
Best for families
Wendell Connor Car Rentals
Choose this if you need a minivan, Jeep Wrangler, or larger vehicle, or want maximum flexibility with three island pickup locations.
Compare Car Rental Companies
Use this table to compare starting rates, ratings, and pickup convenience before choosing an agency.
Agency Comparison Table
Ratings, starting rates, and pickup availability.
| Agency | Rating | From | Airport | Ferry | Hotel |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Bryan's Car Rentals Best overall | 4.9 | $45/day | |||
Andy's Auto Rentals Best value | 4.7 | $35/day | — | ||
Wendell Connor Car Rentals Best for families | 4.7 | $30/day |
Best Car Rental Companies Reviewed
Here is a more detailed look at each rental company and who each one is best for.
Rank
#1
Bryan's Car Rentals
200+ reviews
From
$45/day
Best overall choice for most visitors. Ronnie Bryan pre-positions your car at the airport or ferry with the key hidden and details sent by email. You arrive and drive away. Clean, well-maintained fleet and a track record of excellent service.
Pickup Locations
Vehicle Types
Rank
#2
Andy's Auto Rentals
150+ reviews
From
$35/day
Best for budget-focused travelers who want a practical rental and can communicate via WhatsApp. Staff meet you at the ferry terminal desk or airport. Rates from $35/day make this one of the more affordable verified options on the island.
Pickup Locations
Vehicle Types
Rank
#3
Wendell Connor Car Rentals
180+ reviews
From
$30/day
Best for families, groups, and travelers who want maximum flexibility. With three pickup locations (airport, ferry terminal, and main office), a wide fleet including minivans and Jeep Wranglers, and rates from $30/day, Wendell Connor is one of the island's most established and practical options.
Pickup Locations
Vehicle Types
How We Rate Agencies
A good car rental company should make your trip easier, not more complicated. These are the areas that matter most.
Customer Reviews
We look at overall satisfaction, communication, pickup experience, reliability, and how easy the agency is to work with.
Vehicle Quality
A good rental company should offer clean, well-maintained vehicles that match the type of trip visitors are planning.
Pricing Transparency
Clear pricing matters. Travelers should understand daily rates, deposits, insurance, permit fees, fuel rules, and delivery charges.
Pickup Convenience
Airport, ferry terminal, and hotel pickup can make a major difference, especially for visitors arriving with luggage or family.
Keep Planning Your Rental
Use these guides to compare pickup locations, driving rules, and whether renting a car makes sense for your trip.
Car Rental Questions Answered
Common questions visitors have when planning a car rental in Anguilla.
Do I need to book a car rental in advance in Anguilla?
Pre-booking is strongly recommended, especially during high season (December through April) and around Carnival. The best local agencies have limited fleets, and waiting until arrival often means limited choice or no availability.
What documents do I need to rent a car in Anguilla?
You need a valid driver's license from your home country and a credit card or deposit method. All visitors must also purchase a temporary Anguillan driving permit ($25 USD), which most agencies arrange at pickup.
Do rental cars in Anguilla have automatic transmission?
Most do. Automatic vehicles are widely available from all major local agencies. If you specifically need a manual transmission vehicle, confirm availability with your agency at the time of booking.
Is there a lot of traffic on the roads in Anguilla?
No. Anguilla has very light traffic compared to most places. Outside of a few busier stretches near The Valley, most roads are calm and easy to navigate, which is especially reassuring for visitors adjusting to left-side driving.
Can I pick up a car at the Blowing Point ferry terminal?
Yes. Bryan's Car Rentals, Andy's Auto Rentals, and Wendell Connor Car Rentals all offer pickup at the Blowing Point Ferry Terminal in addition to AXA airport. Confirm your preferred location when booking.
Match the agency to your arrival and island plans
Choose based on where you arrive, what vehicle you need, how much support you want, and whether you plan to explore beaches beyond the main roads.
About the author
Jahmal RichardAnguilla Local
Jahmal Richard is a born-and-raised Anguillian who regularly uses the Blowing Point ferry crossing for personal and business travel. He built Anguilla Ferry Times to give travelers clear, locally verified ferry schedules, practical planning tools, and honest island guidance. Read Jahmal’s background · Editorial policy →